I began the following list during my days as full-time sports editor at the Circleville Herald and it’s been updated through the years as more players have earned their way on and as research has found more pre-consolidation players who qualify. If you know of anyone else from Pickaway County or what is now the Amanda-Clearcreek school district who should be on the list, please let me know.

Shayna Harmon (Teays Valley, 2013-16), 1,893

Ridge Young (Logan Elm, 2014-17), 1,798

David Myers (Williamsport, 1957-60), 1,796

Alyssa Evans (Amanda-Clearcreek, 2015-19), 1,776

Maren McCallister (Hew Hope, 2019-2023), 1,752

Mindy Fusetti (Teays Valley,1995-99), 1,728

Michelle Estell (Amanda-Clearcreek, 1995-99), 1,640

Tom Rathburn (Ashville, 1958-62), 1,632

Bob Hoover (Ashville, 1956-60), 1,625

Tyler Evans (Logan Elm, 2001-05), 1,589

Kenzie McConnell (Circleville, 2017-2021), 1,570
Harold Gerhardt (Atlanta, 1951-1955), 1,558
Alicia Miller (Amanda-Clearcreek, 1995-99), 1,452
Dale Lambert (Teays Valley 1967-70), 1,444
Casse Mogan (Circleville, 2004-08), 1,427
Isaac Ward (Logan Elm, 2017-2021) 1,379
Tyler Schleich (Westfall, 1997-2000), 1,360
Clayton Rhyne (Amanda-Clearcreek & New Hope, 2019-2023), 1,359
Dillon Young (Logan Elm, 2011-14), 1,332
Tim Congrove (Logan Elm, 2005-08), 1,287
Abby Hatter (Logan Elm, 2016-2020), 1,287
Aaron Kanitz (Circleville, 1993-97), 1,265
Nate Anderson (Teays Valley, 2007-2011), 1,251
Noah Highfield (New Hope Christian Acad., 2014-18), 1,234
Jason McFarland (Logan Elm, 1992-95), 1,209
P.J. Stiles (Teays Valley, 1978-80), 1,207
Sara Hildenbrand (Circleville, 1996-2000), 1,200
Isaac Roese (New Hope Christian Acad., 2014-18), 1,188
Thom Patete (Westfall, 1993-97), 1,173
Staci Ballou (Circleville, 1988-92), 1,167
Misti Halley (Logan Elm, 1992-95), 1,161
Dave Smith (Pickaway, 1953-57), 1,157
Gail Adams (Logan Elm, 1988-92), 1,145
Evan Blake (Logan Elm, 2002-06), 1,140
Jerry Mowry (Westfall, 1977-81), 1,135
Chris Rollins (Amanda-Clearcreek 2000-03), 1,127
Tony Picklesimer (Westfall, 1992-95), 1,126
Emily Robinson (Logan Elm, 2007-11), 1,124
Stephanie Garrett (Circleville, 1988-92), 1,121
Sheri Reed (Logan Elm, 1984-88), 1,121
Brandon Amann (Logan Elm, 2005-09), 1,119
Teresa Stonerock (Westfall, 1978-81), 1,117
Tara Wright (Westfall, 1997-2000), 1,113
Paula Everts (Teays Valley, 1988) 1,111
Jimi Anderson (Amanda-Clearcreek, 1999-2002), 1,110
Andy Hulse (Logan Elm, 1988-92), 1,099
Holly Hastings (Teays Valley, 1985) 1,099
Luke McConnell (Circleville, 1981-84), 1,092
Jordin Blakeman (Circleville, 2013-2017), 1,091
Will Riffle (Amanda-Clearcreek, 2015-19), 1,097
Maddie Snider (Amanda-Clearcreek, 2013-17), 1,077
Kelsie Robinson (Westfall, 2013-16), 1,073
Tom Sykes (Logan Elm, 1970-73), 1,072
Bridget Oberer (Teays Valley, 1993-96), 1,061
Gene Stonerock (Circleville & Williamsport, 1952-56), 1,053
Alyssia Morris (AC, 1999-2002), 1,050
Ashley Hoskins (Circleville, 1989-92), 1,045
Ryan Wolfe (Teays Valley, 2015-2019), 1,040
Regan Stonerock (Westfall, 2013-16), 1,039
Tim Stonerock (Circleville, 1964-67), 1,029
Dave Truex (Circleville, 1971-74), 1,016
Marcy Dudgeon (Westfall, 2016-2020), 1,016
Craig Stewart (Circleville, 2000-03), 1,013
Shane Roese (Teays Valley, 1984-88), 1,011
Tyler Primmer (Teays Valley, 2010-14), 1,006